Alabama's playoff cushion shrinks as Texas closes in

By JR·2 min read
Alabama's playoff cushion shrinks as Texas closes in

TLDR: Alabama climbed to No. 6 in the AP poll Sunday, but ESPN's model gives the Tide just a 57% playoff shot at 9-3 if they lose the Iron Bowl, with Texas closing in.

Beating Chattanooga 47-0 on Senior Day was supposed to be a stress-free Saturday. Then the computers saw Alabama's schedule.

Mike Rodak
Mike Rodak
@mikerodak

Alabama’s strength of schedule on ESPN fell from No. 6 to No. 18 after playing Chattanooga, with gap widening for Texas and gap closing with Tennessee. Texas now has ESPN’s No. 4 strength of record and No. 6 strength of schedule. Alabama has ESPN’s No. 6 strength of record and No. 18 strength of schedule. Tennessee has ESPN’s No. 7 strength of record and No. 20 strength of schedule.

Mike Rodak: Alabama’s strength of schedule on ESPN fell from No. 6 to No. 18 after playing Chattanooga, with gap widening for Texas
Mike Rodak
Mike Rodak
@mikerodak

Here are ESPN’s strength of record, strength of schedule (only including games played) and remaining strength of schedule (games yet to be played). The CFP uses different numbers. t.co/tXf52CIYpl t.co/cMSMhKADvn

That's what happens when you swap an SEC opponent for an FCS school in November. Alabama's strength of schedule dropped from No. 6 to No. 18 in one afternoon. Texas now sits ahead of the Tide in both strength of record and strength of schedule, and Tennessee is right on their heels in both. That matters because the committee had Alabama at No. 3 and Texas at No. 5 last week, and ESPN's Heather Dinich is already projecting the 2 flipping when the new rankings drop Tuesday night: Texas at 3, Alabama at 4.

The market isn't worried yet. ESPN's model still gives the Tide a better than 9-in-10 shot at the field, but even that number slipped after Saturday's results.

Mike Rodak
Mike Rodak
@mikerodak

Is Alabama a playoff lock regardless of the Iron Bowl? Alabama is currently -20000 to make the playoff on FanDuel and +3000 to miss it, while ESPN's probability of Tide making the playoff dropped from 97% to 92% after Saturday's results. t.co/PCE0Xpr28O

Minus-20000 is basically the sportsbook calling it a lock. ESPN's playoff predictor isn't nearly that sure, though, and the gap between those 2 numbers is the whole story heading into rivalry week. Plug in a loss to Auburn and the floor drops out.

Nick Kelly
Nick Kelly
@_NickKelly

Alabama has a 57% chance to make the CFP with a loss to Auburn in the Iron Bowl, per ESPN's playoff predictor

57% is a coin flip with a slight lean. A 9-3 Alabama would be asking the committee to wave through a team with a 3rd loss to its biggest rival and an SEC title game spot that's already a long shot. The Tide need a specific mess to get to Atlanta: win and have Texas lose to Texas A&M and Tennessee lose to Vanderbilt, or have all 3 teams finish the same way and hope the tiebreakers break their way. Anything else and Alabama is watching championship weekend from the couch.

Sunday's polls didn't do much to clear it up. The coaches moved Alabama up 2 spots to No. 5, one spot ahead of Texas, after UCLA and Indiana lost. The AP poll moved the Tide up just 1 spot to No. 6, still behind Texas at No. 5 and just ahead of Tennessee at No. 7. The AP ranking also exposes the résumé problem. Kentucky dropped out of the AP top 25, which leaves Alabama without a single win over a team currently ranked there. In the coaches poll, the Wildcats hang on at No. 25, and that's the only ranked win the Tide have left.

Alabama's best argument is how it has won. Last week CFP chair Hunter Yurachek pointed to the Tide's margins in SEC play, and those numbers still look good next to the rest of the contenders.

Nick Kelly
Nick Kelly
@_NickKelly

Last week, CFP chair Hunter Yurachek highlighted by how much Alabama had won its SEC victories. So FWIW, here's the average scoring margin of victory in wins over SEC teams for CFP contenders: Georgia: 24 Alabama: 22.67 Texas: 15.83 Tennessee: 15

Nearly 23 points a game against the SEC trails only Georgia, and it's a full touchdown better than Texas and Tennessee. That's what the Tide will be selling Tuesday night, and it's why the committee might keep them at No. 3 anyway. What happens Saturday matters more. Alabama hosts Auburn on November 28. A win puts them at 10-2 and the odds mostly take care of themselves. A loss hands the decision to 13 people in a hotel conference room, and the metrics say they could go either way.

Free Picks