Cal Ritchie nears Islanders return after Hamilton tune-up

By JR·2 min read
Cal Ritchie nears Islanders return after Hamilton tune-up

TLDR: The Islanders activated Cal Ritchie off injured reserve Wednesday and loaned him to AHL Hamilton, a month after a lower-body injury against Toronto that was supposed to cost him 4-6 weeks.

This isn't a demotion. It's a conditioning stint, and Hamilton's schedule sets it up almost perfectly.

Andrew Gross
Andrew Gross
@AGrossNewsday

Hamilton hosts Belleville on Friday, then doesn't play again until a week from today. Could see Ritchie getting that one game and then rejoining #Isles when they get home to face Maple Leafs on Monday.

Andrew Gross
Andrew Gross
@AGrossNewsday

#Isles activate C Cal Ritchie (lower body) - hurt on Oct. 17 and expected to miss 4-6 weeks - and loan him to Hamilton (AHL) to get some games in.

So Ritchie probably gets one game, Friday at home against Belleville, while Hamilton then sits for a week. That points straight at Monday, when the Isles get home to face the Maple Leafs. There's a little symmetry there. Ritchie got hurt against Toronto on Oct. 17, on his first shift of a 4-1 Islanders win. A Monday return would land a bit over 5 weeks later, right inside the original 4-6 week estimate.

In case you forgot how the Isles got him: Colorado took Ritchie 27th overall in 2023, and he came to Long Island in the March 2025 Brock Nelson trade, along with Oliver Kylington, a 2026 1st-round pick and a conditional 2028 3rd. He's 21 and played 8 games before the injury, with a goal, an assist and 12:11 of ice time a night. That isn't a breakout yet, but it's a young center the front office paid real value for, and he was already getting a regular NHL shift.

The timing matters because the Islanders just lost a center. J-G Pageau is out with a lower-body injury of his own, though it isn't expected to be a long one, and Mathew Barzal was talking up the team's forward depth after last night's game.

Once Ritchie and a healthy Pageau are both available, the Isles have more forwards than lineup spots, and that's a good problem to have. Andrew Gross went ahead and tried to fit everyone in.

Andrew Gross
Andrew Gross
@AGrossNewsday

Just spitballin' Holmstrom-Horvat-Palmieri Maccelli-Ritchie-Barzal Heineman-Schenn-Eklund Three spots for: Pageau, Palat, Duclair, Cizikas, Chaffee Eklund could swap with Palmieri but you hate to break up his chemistry with Schenn #OptionsAreGood

Andrew Gross
Andrew Gross
@AGrossNewsday

Assuming Cal Ritchie rejoins #Isles perhaps next week and J-G Pageau's absence from a lower-body injury isn't a long one, which it's not expected to be, I think Mathew Barzal's enthusiasm after last night's game about team's forward depth is very fair.

Gross's version has Ritchie centering the second line between Matias Maccelli and Barzal. Pageau, Ondrej Palat, Anthony Duclair, Casey Cizikas and Chaffee would be fighting over the last 3 spots. Gross admits it's spitballing, and he points out that moving Eklund would split him up from Schenn. Still, a team that was thin down the middle a month ago is now picking which veterans sit.

What to watch next: Friday in Hamilton, where a clean game should mean Ritchie is cleared, and then Monday vs. the Leafs. If he plays Monday, the Isles get their young center back against the same team he got hurt against.

Free Picks