Baker Mayfield faces Browns as Deshaun Watson trade fallout resurfaces

TLDR: Browns OC Travis Switzer previewed what he needs from Deshaun Watson against the Buccaneers this week, while Browns defenders Carson Schwesinger and Jared Verse both said they're eager to make Baker Mayfield pay for his three fumbles and are motivated to avoid another slow start after last week's Jaguars loss.
Sunday's Browns-Bucs game is a lot more than a Week 3 matchup. It's Baker Mayfield walking back into the building that gave up on him, across from the quarterback Cleveland traded three first-round picks and a $230 million guaranteed deal to get instead. Watson is 20 games into that deal. Mayfield has thrown almost as many touchdowns as Watson has attempted starts, and the receipts are getting passed around Cleveland's building this week.

The Browns traded a package including 3 first-round picks for Deshaun Watson in March 2022, then traded Baker Mayfield to the Panthers for a 5th-round pick. Since that trade… Baker Mayfield has 105 pass TD (5th-most in the NFL) Deshaun Watson has 20 pass TD (T-43rd most in NFL)
That stat line isn't a hot take, it's just the box score of the trade: since Cleveland shipped Mayfield to Carolina for a 5th-round pick, he's thrown 105 touchdown passes, 5th-most in the NFL. Watson has thrown 20 in that same window. Mayfield now has more career wins (29) than Watson has games played for the Browns (20) — a gap that's only going to look worse the longer Watson stays banged up and inconsistent.
It's not just outsiders piling on. Bucs assistant Ken Zampese, who coached Cleveland's quarterbacks in Mayfield's rookie year, said flatly this week that the Browns "mucked it up" letting him go.

Bucs assistant Ken Zampese, who was Cleveland's QB coach in 2018, says the Browns "mucked it up" with Baker Mayfield. t.co/UrT85kJhe4
Zampese was there in 2018 when Mayfield helped flip a 1-31 Browns team into a 5-3 finish down the stretch — the moment Cleveland finally looked like it had its guy. Then came the messy split, the trade for Watson, and a QB competition Watson still hasn't fully won even three seasons later. Browns OC Travis Switzer has been vocal this week about what he needs to see out of Watson against Tampa, and head coach Todd Monken has been careful not to frame Sunday as some kind of audition, even though everyone watching knows exactly what it is.
Watson, for his part, sounds tired of the scrutiny. Asked whether he needs a big game to lock down the home opener start against Carolina on Sept. 27, he pushed back on the standard being applied to him.
Nobody's actually demanding 400 yards and 5 touchdowns a week, but the frustration in Watson's answer says plenty about where his confidence sits three seasons into a contract that was supposed to make this an easy call. Mayfield, meanwhile, has made peace with how it ended. Asked about his lone year in Cleveland under Monken, he didn't sugarcoat it.
That 2019 season was rough for both sides — Mayfield regressed, Monken's offense never clicked, and the Browns moved on within a few years. Now Monken is running Cleveland's offense with Watson instead, and Mayfield is the one walking into Cleveland with a Super Bowl-caliber résumé being built somewhere else. Whatever happens Sunday, the box score everyone's already circling is the one from the trade itself — and right now, it isn't close.
More Stories
Minkah Fitzpatrick fined for KC Concepcion hit
Carson Schwesinger ankle injury: Browns LB day-to-day vs. Ravens
KC Concepcion injury Minkah Fitzpatrick hit Browns vs. Jets
Mike Evans injury update: 49ers WR back at practice
Jaylen Harrell car crash Tampa: police allege assault
CeeDee Lamb fined $23,882 for helmet hit on 49ers block


