Feitelberg doubts Sofia Franklyn's Barstool party story

TLDR: The new How'd We Get Here takes John Feitelberg back to the 2018 Barstool Christmas party, and he says he suspects Sofia Franklyn lied about it, mostly because he never saw any of it.
Feits shot this one the way he shoots all of them: alone on a bench by the water with a microphone, talking about a night most of Barstool would rather forget.

“The 2018 Barstool Christmas party, I have a suspicion that Sofia Franklin was lying about it… Because I was in the bathroom doing cocaine for sure. Didn’t see them” -John Feitelberg
Don't read it as a deposition. It's a bit. Feits's whole alibi is a self-own: he spent the party locked in the bathroom, so he never saw the people Franklyn writes about, and he's skeptical of anyone who says they saw anything. A guy whose defense amounts to "I wasn't in the room" is in no position to fact-check anybody, and he knows it. That's the joke.
Here's why the party is a topic in the first place. Franklyn's memoir, Daddy Issues, came out November 10, and the Barstool holiday party is one of its biggest chapters. She writes that she was anxious, drank too much and ended up in a fight with Alex Cooper. Cooper then told her that everyone, Dave Portnoy included, had noticed and wanted her off the show. By Franklyn's account, when she finally went to apologize, Portnoy waved it off as "the girls got in a fight." She also writes that Cooper used the fallout to get herself $20,000 a year more than Franklyn.
So a holiday party that was mostly folklore inside the company now sits at the center of the Call Her Daddy origin story, and Barstool people who were around back then keep getting asked about it. Plenty of the people on the roster today joined after all of it, and some have said exactly that on air.
“I don't really know the ins and outs of Sofia. I don't know much about Call Her Daddy at all, like that was pre-me at Barstool.” – Brianna Chickenfry
Feits was there, though. That's the point of How'd We Get Here: he goes back to a place and walks through the story. Most guys would show up to this one with receipts. He brought a punchline about the bathroom, and the waterfront crowd was apparently a tough one to read.
The real question is whether anyone else from the 2018 party starts telling their own version now that Franklyn's is in print. Cooper hasn't put out a chapter-by-chapter response. Portnoy's line is the one the book itself quotes. Until somebody with an actual memory of the night talks, the Barstool side of the story belongs to a guy who says he was in the bathroom the whole time.
More Stories
Stu Feiner hypes Fasoli wedding seat next to Dave Portnoy
Feits says he refused Michael Rapaport interviews
Feits How'd We Get Here Washington Square Park episode
Steven Cheah watches Marvel movies for the first time
Barstool Greg misses flight, Burns takes off without him
Paul Bissonnette Peakin episode at Mount Washington




