Joe Milton replaces Tanner McKee as Eagles face Giants

TLDR: Nick Sirianni benched Tanner McKee after an 0-3 run as the starter, so Joe Milton gets his first NFL start Sunday against a Giants team favored by 3.5 in Philadelphia.
Milton has been an Eagle for 3 weeks. Now he's the guy, and he says the man he replaced is helping him get ready.
That's a classy move from McKee, because the way this went down was ugly. On Monday Sirianni stood at the podium and said, "Tanner's our guy. We're not making any changes there." He also put the 6-game losing streak on the coaches, not the quarterback. 2 days later McKee was on the bench. Sirianni was asked about it Friday, and his answer was basically that McKee did nothing wrong, the coach just needed to do something.
McKee's numbers back up the "solid" part. Since Jalen Hurts went on IR with blood clots in his calf, McKee went 72-of-114 for 638 yards with 2 touchdowns and 2 picks. The problem is the record: 0-3, and it ended with the Eagles blowing a 10-0 lead to Washington and losing 27-10. A team that opened 2-0 has now lost 6 straight. When your offense can't block and keeps stalling, swapping the quarterback is the one lever a head coach can pull himself. Also worth noting: Sirianni says he made no changes to his staff. So the QB takes the fall.
Milton is a totally different player. He was a 2024 6th-round pick of the Patriots, has played in 5 career games, all off the bench, and the Eagles signed him off Dallas' practice squad on October 16. He's 26, he's got a cannon, and he can run, which matters behind this line. He also makes mistakes. Nobody is pretending this is a long-term answer. It's a bet that some chaos beats another week of punts.
And Vegas is telling you how bad things have gotten. This rivalry has gone one way for a long time.
The Eagles had been favored in 19 straight meetings with the Giants, playoffs included. Now New York is laying 3.5 at the Linc, which hasn't happened since Week 16 of 2016. If Milton hits a couple of deep shots and pulls this off, Sirianni looks smart for a week. If the Giants roll into South Philly and win as favorites, Sirianni benched a quarterback he called solid and has nothing to show for it, and the questions get pointed at him next.
More Stories
Nick Sirianni hot seat after Eagles lose to Commanders 27-10
Andy Dalton signs with Falcons, Cooper Rush released
Jalen Hurts blood clot injury: Eagles place QB on IR
Mike Evans injury update: 49ers WR back at practice
Jaylen Harrell car crash Tampa: police allege assault
CeeDee Lamb fined $23,882 for helmet hit on 49ers block

