Max Scherzer refuses to leave in possible final start

TLDR: Max Scherzer argued his way past 104 pitches, threw 114 in a 5-1 Blue Jays win over the Reds, and finished 3 strikeouts shy of Justin Verlander in what may be his last start.
- Fri Sep 256:03 PM CT
Verlander Says Goodbye First
You can't tell this story without the other guy. Scherzer and Justin Verlander have chased each other around the league for 20 years: both came up as Tigers aces, both won Cy Youngs, both hung around well into their 40s, and both have been climbing the all-time strikeout list one spot behind the other. Verlander had already announced his last start was coming Saturday in Detroit, and on Friday night he stood in front of the home crowd and told them where he belongs.
Barstool Baseball@StoolBaseball"I am, and always will be, a Detroit Tiger." Justin Verlander soaks in his final weekend of a Hall of Fame career
The strikeout race was already the storyline. Scherzer was lined up to pitch Sunday in Toronto, sitting just behind Verlander on the career list, and the beat writers were asking Verlander about it before he'd even thrown his final pitch.
Verlander's farewell was the sure thing. Scherzer's was the question mark, and he was about to explain why.
Mad Max Leaves The Door Open
Saturday morning, Scherzer met with reporters in Toronto and didn't call it a retirement. He'll decide in the offseason. What he did want was 1 more start at Rogers Centre with his kids in the building, just in case this is it.
He also shot down the idea that he was going Sunday to chase Verlander's number. He said he'd been texting with Verlander and wanted him to punch out everybody in his final start. Take that however you want. Nobody alive believes Max Scherzer doesn't know exactly where he sits on a leaderboard.
It was also a short-rest start. According to the AP, Scherzer had thrown 93 pitches 5 days earlier and took the ball anyway for Game 162. That's about as Scherzer as it gets.
- Sat Sep 2612:15 PM CT
Verlander's Last Walk
Saturday afternoon belonged to Detroit. Verlander, pitching a Tigers home game for the first time since 2017, took the mound one last time to a crowd that had been waiting all weekend for it.
The exit is the part everyone will remember. As he was being pulled, his daughter Genevieve ran out to meet him on the mound, and the stadium lost it. It's 1 of the better goodbyes you'll see in this sport.
Foul Territory@FoulTerritoryTVJustin Verlander’s final career start ended with his daughter running out to meet him on the mound. What a moment in Detroit. 🥹
Then the Tigers finished it off. Rookie Eduardo Valencia hit a walk-off homer the same afternoon Verlander made his last start, which is the kind of script nobody would buy in a movie.
Foul Territory@FoulTerritoryTVTIGERS ROOKIE EDUARDO VALENCIA HITS A WALK-OFF HOMER ON THE DAY JUSTIN VERLANDER MAKES HIS FINAL CAREER START! WHAT A WAY TO END THE DAY IN DETROIT. 🔥
Verlander left with 3,560 career strikeouts, eighth all-time. That put the number on the board for Scherzer to go after on Sunday, whether or not he'd admit he was going after it.
- Sun Sep 272:13 PM CT
Scherzer Takes The Ball
Sunday was a sellout at Rogers Centre, and the crowd was on its feet before Scherzer threw a pitch. Toronto was 79-83 and going nowhere, so the season finale was all about him.
He was dealing, too. The 7th strikeout came on his 97th pitch, and the whole building stood up for that one as well.
Rob Friedman@PitchingNinjaEveryone on their feet for Max Scherzer's 7th K of the game on his 97th pitch 👏👏👏
After 6 innings he had 7 punchouts and was 3 away from tying Verlander for eighth all-time. He came off the mound yelling like it was October.
Talkin' Baseball@TalkinBaseball_Max Scherzer is fired up as he is through six innings with seven strikeouts He is three strikeouts away from tying Justin Verlander (3560) for eighth all-time in strikeouts
Sitting at 3,557 with a pitch count already in the 90s, he was running out of runway. You already know he wasn't going to be the one to say so.
- Sun Sep 274:05 PM CT
104 Pitches And Not Leaving
At pitch 104, John Schneider came out to get him, and Scherzer did the most Scherzer thing possible: he refused to go. He talked his way into the 8th inning of a meaningless season finale, on short rest, at 42.
He ended up at 114 pitches, a season high, and left with 1 run allowed over 7-plus innings. The walk off the mound got the loudest ovation of the day.
He didn't get Verlander, falling 3 strikeouts short. What he got was win number 225 and one more reminder of why he's been the most stubborn pitcher of his generation.
The Psychopath Postgame
The best line of the weekend came from Schneider, who explained what he said to Scherzer on the mound when he finally got the ball back. It was a thank-you, plus the best compliment you can give a guy like Max.
Scherzer's own postgame answer about how he felt out there works as his whole career in 4 words.
So where does that leave it? Verlander is done, eighth all-time with 3,560. Scherzer is ninth with 3,557 and says he'll decide this winter. If this was his last start, he went out arguing with his manager and throwing 114 pitches on short rest, which is exactly how he pitched for 19 years. If it wasn't, the 3 strikeouts separating him from Verlander give him a pretty obvious reason to come back.
More Stories
Myles Straw free agent after Blue Jays decline option
Chris Paddack wins Korean Series with Samsung Lions
Logan Gilbert, Steven Kwan trade unlikely in November
Tai Peete AFL Home Run Derby runner-up to Aaron Parker
Jazz Chisholm Jr. Aaron Judge stern warning Yankees report
Mark Trumbo on Angels GM search and minor league coaches

