Big Cat roasts Kirk Herbstreit over his dog's steak dinner

By JR·2 min read
Big Cat roasts Kirk Herbstreit over his dog's steak dinner

TLDR: Kirk Herbstreit fed steak to his golden retriever Peter off a plate inside a New York City steakhouse, and on Monday Big Cat and the Yak both piled on.

Herbstreit has been bringing his dogs on the road for years, and the internet mostly loved it. This video got a very different reaction.

Barstool Sports
Barstool Sports
@barstoolsports

Kirk Herbstreit has set the internet on fire once again, this time for bringing his Golden Retreiever into a steakhouse and letting it eat off a plate t.co/wtA03Tdi49

Here's what happened. On Thursday night at a high-end steakhouse in NYC, Herbstreit cut a steak into small pieces, put the plate down on the floor, and Peter ate it. Herbstreit filmed the whole thing and posted it. By Friday, Craig Carton was going after him on air, saying Herbstreit "doesn't care about your opportunity to enjoy yourself" and arguing that Kirk "has to constantly feed the algorithm." Most of the anger online was about hygiene: a dog eating off a restaurant plate, at a place where people are paying a lot for their food.

Big Cat had his own read on it during Monday's Pardon My Take. He didn't really say whether Herbstreit was right or wrong. He gave him credit, sort of, for running an experiment on the rest of us.

That's the real question here. Herbstreit's dogs have pretty much been off-limits for criticism. America loves a golden retriever on a College GameDay set, and nobody wants to be the guy yelling at a dog. Taking one into a fancy steakhouse and handing it the plate looks like it might be where that goodwill runs out. Plenty of the replies said it out loud. You can love dogs and still not want one eating off the china next to your table.

The Yak also got into it on Monday's show. One of the hosts was openly happy about the pile-on, saying it proved a point he's been making for a long time.

Viva La Stool
Viva La Stool
@VivaLaStool

You’ll never guess who’s happy about the backlash Herbstreit is getting for this…

Barstool Sports
Barstool Sports
@barstoolsports

“I’m gonna give Kirk Herbstreit some credit, he’s really testing to see how much we love dogs” -Big Cat t.co/qCVnbaWP34

Will Herbstreit actually change anything? Probably not. Peter is part of the brand at this point, and the dog content does huge numbers, which was Carton's whole complaint. But this is the first time the internet has pushed back on Herbstreit's dog bits in a big way. If the next road trip ends at another white-tablecloth spot, plenty of people will be watching to see where Peter eats.

Free Picks