Dombrowski tells Trea Turner to fix his defense or move

Dombrowski did his end-of-season presser after the Phillies' early playoff exit, and the Turner question came up early. His answer was yes, for now.

That isn't a ringing endorsement. It's a probation notice, and Dombrowski didn't leave much room to read it any other way. He went further than 'play well.' He picked out the exact season he wants back and the one he never wants to see again.

Foul Territory

@FoulTerritoryTV

Dave Dombrowski told Trea Turner it's "mandatory" that he's better defensively at shortstop. "If he plays shortstop as he did in 2025, then he can play the position. If he plays it as he did in 2026, he can't." Dombrowski added that Turner is "very willing" to do what's best for the organization if he doesn't play shortstop.

The gap between those 2 seasons is huge. In 2025 Turner was great on both sides of the ball and finished 5th in NL MVP voting. In 2026 he fell apart everywhere. He made 21 errors at short and posted -17 defensive runs saved, and at the plate he hit.242/.297/.378 over 700 plate appearances. It was the worst year of his career, and Dombrowski said so: he needs to fix his swing, and he knows he has to be better at shortstop.

The timing makes it worse. The Phillies went 88-74, got the last wild-card spot on the final day of the season and were then knocked out by the Braves in a 3-game Wild Card Series. A team with this payroll and this core can't afford a shortstop who's a liability with the glove and a below-average bat. Turner is only in Year 5 of the 11-year, $300 million deal he signed in December 2022, which runs through 2033. That money doesn't move. The position can.

The front office is already acting on it. Philly hired Carlos Mendoza, the former Mets manager who got fired in June, as its new 3rd base and infield coach, and Dombrowski said Turner has been working on his swing and his fielding since the season ended. The fallback options are already lined up: top prospect Aidan Miller, who has limited Triple-A experience and some back injury concerns; Bryan Rincon, a capable defender at short; and Bryson Stott, who has been playing 3rd but can handle shortstop.

So where would Turner go? Dombrowski pointed out that he has played the outfield before, though he prefers the infield, and he called Turner 'very willing' to do whatever is best for the club. That's the polite version. The real one: show up in Clearwater playing like the 2025 guy, or spend 2027 learning how to read balls off the wall at Citizens Bank Park. Spring training just became a tryout for a $300 million player.